A lead list is not a list of names. It is a list of people who fit your offer, have an email that will land, and get a first line written for them. Here is the exact workflow we use, run on a sample ICP so you can follow every step.
The sample ICP
This ICP is made up for this post:
| Field | Our example |
|---|---|
| Company type | IT managed service providers (MSPs) |
| Location | United States |
| Company size | 10 to 100 employees |
| Decision-makers | Founder, CEO, owner, head of sales |
| Buying signal | Hiring salespeople, or a website that offers managed security |
| Offer | Done-for-you outbound to win new IT support contracts |
Write the ICP down before you pull a single lead. Every later step, from scoring to personalization, checks leads against it.
Step 1: Source the leads
We pull decision-makers that match the ICP filters from a B2B database. AI Ark and Apollo both work well here. AI Ark adds lookalike search, which finds companies similar to your best clients.
The filters do the rough cut: industry, country, headcount and job title. Expect noise. A database tag of “IT services” will also bring in software agencies, recruiters and resellers who do not fit.
Step 2: Qualify with AI
Next, AI reads each company’s website and answers simple yes-or-no questions from the ICP:
- Do they sell managed IT services, or something else?
- Do they serve businesses in the US?
- Is the person a real decision-maker for sales?
We run this in Clay, with the AI working from the live website rather than the database tag. This is the step that removes most of the noise from Step 1.
Step 3: Score every lead
Qualified leads then get a score from 0 to 100 against the ICP, with a one-line written reason for each score. Size fit, the buying signal, title and location all add points.
We set a cut-off of 70. For a smaller, very targeted campaign, we raise it to 80. Leads below the cut-off are not deleted; they are set aside in a separate list. If the campaign runs out of high scorers, that list is the first place we look.
The written reason matters. When a client asks why a company is on the list, we can show them.
Step 4: Verify the emails
Only leads above the cut-off move on, which keeps verification costs down. Every email is checked with NeverBounce or ZeroBounce, and each one comes back in one of three groups:
- Valid: goes on to personalization.
- Catch-all or risky: sent in small batches, or re-checked, so it cannot push the bounce rate up.
- Invalid or missing: goes to enrichment.
The goal is a bounce rate under 2%. Bounces are one of the fastest ways to damage a sending domain.
Step 5: Enrich the leads without a good email
A good lead with a bad email is still a good lead. For these, we run a waterfall in Clay: several email-finding providers are tried one after another until one returns an address. Every new address goes back through verification before it is used.
This step usually recovers a useful share of strong leads that most teams would simply throw away.
Step 6: Personalize
Now every lead has a fit score and a verified email. AI reads their website and recent activity and writes a short first line that mentions something real, such as a new service, a recent hire or a client type they serve.
A person reviews the lines before anything is sent. AI is fast, but it sometimes picks the wrong detail, and one odd first line can cost a reply.
Step 7: Upload to the campaign
The finished list is uploaded to the sending tool (Instantly, Smartlead or PlusVibe), with each lead’s first line and score as custom fields. Leads go to mailboxes that match their email provider: Google-hosted leads to Google mailboxes, Microsoft-hosted leads to Microsoft mailboxes.
Only at this point does a lead enter a campaign. Nothing goes out until all six steps before it are complete.
The workflow at a glance
The diagram shows the full flow, including the two side paths: leads that score too low, and leads whose email fails verification.
Want this done for your market?
We run this full workflow for B2B teams, from the ICP to the uploaded campaign. Book a 30-minute strategy call and we will map it to your market.